Will the arts follow Lehman Bros. into the tank?

Filed under:Barry Johnson — posted by Barry Johnson on September 18, 2008 @ 6:46 am

When the economy gets bad, Recession bad, the common understanding is that the arts suffer even worse. And the Wall Street, sub-prime loan crash looks like it may kick the rest of the economy into R-word land, once and for all. So, arts groups are headed for the hills, where they will attempt to hunker down and hold out to the last mime, right? Well, no, not according to David Segal and Jacqueline Trescott in the Washington Post, who surveyed arts groups in New York, mostly, but also Washington to see what the mood was.

Segal and Trescott, perhaps expecting to find panic, ran into a pocket of relative calm. Maybe it’s that corporate giving to the arts is so low in the U.S. — the article says 3 percent of all contributed income — or maybe it’s just blind optimism, but the executive directors refused to buckle. The key quote came at the end:

It’s an article of faith among theater honchos that when the going gets depressing, the depressed go to the theater.

My own theory is that Planet Arts, as the article colorfully calls it, is used to operating near the edge all the time and has confidence in its coping skills. The garden out back. The chickens. The Dumpster diving. Or maybe, as the article suggests, it simply takes a while for economic problems to reach the far-flung planet. Portland isn’t Wall Street, and we have missed much of the direct sub-prime misery that has afflicted California and Florida. But we are not in a bubble here, and the indirect effects are now hitting us (checked your stock portfolio lately? Art Scatter refuses to investigate the one share of Bear Stearns our granny left us).

So, what happens here on our little piece of Planet Arts? I’m not sure. I’ve heard rumblings of majors in trouble for some time now. How resilient will they be if we are facing a one- or two-year Recession? And if the majors ramp up their requests for money from individuals and foundations, will the mid-sized and smaller groups start to feel the pain, too? That’s an honest question… I know lots of Scatter readers work for or are near to arts groups in town. What do you think? What have you heard? Where are we headed? Use the comments section OR if you need more anonymity than that, email us at artscatterpdx@gmail.com.

2 comments »

  1. I suspect that ticket sales won’t decline precipitously over this season. Though corporate support will dry up, it has been steadily eroding in this region anyway. The bigger question is what happens to foundation grants and major individual gifts as portfolios shrink with the stock market? Even if the foundation fund managers and philanthropists have stashed their wealth in safe hidey-holes (or bags of solid gold coins), their gift-making may become more conservative while they ride out the storm. At the same time, competition for those gifts is likely to grow from food banks, homeless shelters, job training centers … and the list goes on. Ultimately, the inherent scrappiness of nonprofit arts managers will be called upon to keep programs afloat–most will survive as they always do. The exception, perhaps, will be those that were already teetering on the edge.

    Comment by MightyToyCannon — September 18, 2008 @ 11:20 am

  2. What organizations get the most from corporate donors? Any sense of alarm from any specific companies?

    Comment by Barry Johnson — September 18, 2008 @ 11:41 am

Copy link for RSS feed for comments on this post or for TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)